|
Chapter 15 Counseling Women - Ida Smith
Counseling women implies certain
responsibilities that are not necessarily unique to counseling in Church
settings but that are crucial to blessing the lives of women in the Church. Too
often, women come away from counseling sessions feeling that they have not
really been listened to, that they have not had an opportunity to state their
entire problem before advice and counsel were given, that their concerns were
not believed or were trivialized by the counselor. Considering this, here are
some general guidelines for counseling with a woman: be honest with her; be a
safe refuge for her; keep her confidences. At first, the support and
understanding she receives from you will be more helpful than any information
you could impart.
Typically, a woman will be
grateful for your comfort and express appreciation for you. If you are a man,
take care not to misread her gratitude and expression of care for you as being
more than she intends. If her thankfulness were more than honest praise, she
would be out of bounds in her feelings, and if you were to respond improperly,
you would be dishonoring your responsibility. If your offer of help has been
genuine, then you are representing the Savior in charity. If her response is
honest, then she is communicating gratitude. It is not uncommon for a counselor
or client to claim to have "fallen in love" with a person they are
seeing. That kind of "love" is a counterfeit of genuine help. By being
concerned but not inappropriately intimate, you can be an oasis of help and
support.
Some Latter-day Saint women feel
that certain situations generated by our culture put even greater pressure on
them than on women generally. Many women simply need a place to express their
feelings, assess their problems, and relieve themselves of burdens, with their
counselors giving no comment, no judgment, no condemnation. Until a woman is
allowed to do this, she will have little room in her mind for the principles and
thoughts you may want to share. The counselor who has empathy, understanding,
and compassion provides refuge for anyone in need of counseling.
As you acknowledge a woman's
suffering, acknowledge also that it will diminish. The pain she feels does not
need to continue at an intense level. It is important to first help reduce her
pain; after her wounds are attended to, she will be less likely to lash out,
inflicting suffering on herself as well as those around her. Do not talk down to
her or say, "You shouldn't feel that way!" Such comments reveal more
about your attitudes than about solutions to her problems. The feelings of those
in emotional pain are real. If you believe, even subconsciously, that she is an
inadequate person, your words and attitude will reveal it. Without your faith in
her abilities and talents, without acknowledging her as capable, you have little
to offer.
Sometimes a woman whose suffering
is hidden may come for help. Her outward appearance, her standing in the Church
or community, or her husband's position may hide her personal struggles. Many
people put on a good facade. Take a woman's cries for help seriously; then you
can assess how desperate she really may be.
Few problems develop overnight. A
woman can be helped by understanding that she can grow out of a problem just as
she grew into it. Like losing weight, psychological and emotional growth need to
be measured in small increments. Sometimes just hanging on is progress, and the desire
to survive is growth. When a woman has suffered serious depression and feels
worthless, help her focus on just fifteen minutes of positive thinking each day,
one day at a time, or to hold one happy thought or feeling every day.
Acknowledging even one happy thought a week may be progress for some.
Help the woman to understand that
it is not possible for you to make everything right for her. She must learn to
do that for herself—with help and support from concerned others. Remember that
often women have been raised in a way that promotes dependence on someone other
than themselves. Often, that someone has been a man—father, husband, bishop,
or stake president. By fostering her own capacities and self-reliance, you can
help her take hold of her own life, including her own emotional health. You can
explain this to her. Elder Boyd K. Packer has spoken of the need for Latter-day
Saints to get off the spiritual dole. fn This is especially true for women who
have been socialized to be dependent on almost every level—physically,
mentally, spiritually, and emotionally.
Be slow to advise and quick to
support. Quick advice is often more judgmental than helpful. Support her in such
a way that she will carry her own burdens. Be wary of the "shoulds"
that you may not be authorized to suggest, such as "You should get
married," "You should not work," or "You should move."
Such prescriptions may ignore more fundamental principles the woman needs to
learn, such as self-understanding and self-reliance.
Sometimes a woman who asks for
counsel will be angry and depressed and not know why. You may find that her
history of dependence has helped cause her to be angry with her husband;
resentful of her children; rebellious toward priesthood, God, the Church, or any
other authority. The solution to these feelings is one she may reject at first:
she may need a closer relationship with God, a better understanding of her own
identity, and a clearer sense of her spiritual mission. She needs to understand
that the root of personal confidence is her own virtue, and that being a partner
in her marriage is an important key to her own salvation. (D&C 132:20.)
The purpose of eternal marriage is
that husband and wife can grow into Godhood together. Marriage must be a
partnership of equals. Contrary to culture or practice, woman is not meant to be
a junior partner in marriage. President Spencer W. Kimball stated in his
September 1978 address to women:
Marriage is a partnership. Each is
given a part of the work of life to do. The fact that some women and men
disregard their work and their opportunities does not change the program. When
we speak of marriage as a partnership, let us speak of marriage as full partnership.
We do not want our LDS women to be silent partners or limited
partners in that eternal assignment! Please be a contributing and full
partner. fn
If a woman has not already assumed
an equal partnership in her marriage, she should be encouraged and counseled to
do so. This may include counseling with her husband, particularly if he sees the
patriarchal role as one of domination and demands rather than one of loving
persuasion and righteous influence as taught in Doctrine and Covenants 121.
Although you must recognize your
own dependence on the Lord as you counsel, do not give the impression that all
you say is of divine inspiration, unless it is and you have the authority to
receive inspiration for that person. As one stake president said, "If you
are inspired, say so! She needs to know it is the Lord speaking and not you
alone. If you feel to advise, let the Lord do it through a blessing, but be very
sure you are doing the right thing for her." Anyone who counsels has a
profound responsibility to be righteous and to discern the will of the Lord.
When Men Counsel Women
The way a male counselor views his relationship with a female he is
counseling is of vital importance. If he feels, however subtly, that he is
superior to her or is just an extension of some other male in her life, he may
give inappropriate advice. But if he sees his role as that of a teacher, guide,
and one who has a right to bless her because of his Church position, then he is
serving her best interests.
Some women may not have had good relationships with their fathers, husbands,
or other men. We sometimes teach children that the love and concern our Heavenly
Father has for us is like the love and concern of our earthly fathers. But if a
woman has not enjoyed the love of an earthly father or husband, she will not
have had that example to teach her about a loving Heavenly Father. Your words
and actions should help her better envision Him. The scriptures counsel that if
we cannot learn to love our imperfect brothers, neighbors, husbands, and others
whom we have seen, we cannot claim to love God whom we have not seen. (See 1
John 4:20-21.)
What if a woman is married to a tyrannical husband who misuses his
priesthood? What is her responsibility? Ideally, of course, it would be to
forgive him. This does not mean she should become a doormat to his
unrighteousness. It simply means that she will do all in her power to pursue a
right course of action herself. Her coming to you with a marital problem
grounded in the unrighteous dominion of her husband is in itself righteous and
responsible. If she has come alone, it is naive to think that her marital
problems will be solved by the two of you alone. A husband must repent of his
unrighteousness if his marriage is to be healed. If the husband does not abandon
his tyranny, there will be no solution.
Too many wives suffer the unrighteous dominion of men who dishonor their
priesthood. Sometimes a man uses "priesthood" to belittle, control, or
even physically abuse a woman. If the woman has difficulty in separating man from
priesthood, help her see that unrighteous behavior of such a man means
"amen" to his priesthood or authority. (See D&C 121:34-37.) When
there is such unrighteousness it does not mean that there is no hope for the
future. On the contrary, when husbands and wives repent and forgive, they can
solve their problems. Your task is to work toward that goal. This usually means
that, at some point, the husband of a woman will also need to be involved in
counseling with you.
Priesthood gives men the governing power in the Church. Men may need to be
counseled that this does not make them better, smarter, more blessed, more
capable of making correct decisions, more inspired, more logical, or more loved
of God than are women.
Righteous priesthood holders recognize the true status of women and know they
are equal to men in spiritual power, divine potential, and responsibility for
their callings. Women need to know that they have just as much right to
inspiration as men do. But often they do not understand their right to
inspiration and revelation and therefore receive none, because they expect none.
Help the women you counsel to recognize their own right to receive personal
revelation. You might ask, "What is your recommendation in this
situation?" You might suggest, "The Lord will reveal your
responsibility to you, so let's examine your reservoir of help."
Women have great recuperative powers, and they must learn to draw upon the Lord
for their strength.
Help each woman you counsel to understand agency and how to choose the right.
Encourage her to study the scriptures and to do her own thinking. If she is
depressed, sees herself in an inferior position, or is angry, she may feel
incapable of praying to a God who she thinks neither hears her nor cares about
her. But such negative feelings can be left behind as she feels the Lord's love
and guidance.
President Spencer W. Kimball has urged the sisters of the Church to become
gospel scholars. They deserve to be challenged to learn and teach correct
doctrine. Occasionally leaders ask only the husband to speak on doctrinal
subjects in sacrament meeting while they ask the wife to speak about her family.
Such assignments will tend to weaken, not strengthen, the woman's resolve to
become a gospel scholar.
The family dimension of a woman's gospel scholarship is especially crucial.
Pearl Buck's statement that "no man ever recovers fully from the ignorance
of his mother" may be even more serious if the ignorance is spiritual. To
underestimate the importance of the woman's spiritual influence in the home is
disastrous. Though a husband and father should be a spiritual leader in the
home, the wife and mother has an equal responsibility to develop her spiritual
leadership.
Myths about Women
There are a number of myths that may distract the counselor, the woman he
counsels, or both. One such myth is that priesthood leaders have ready answers
to questions about family size. Such concerns should be the responsibility of a
wife and a husband with the Lord. Basic questions such as whether to use birth
control and how often to have children should be taken to the Lord by a woman
and her husband. Different couples may receive different answers concerning
their questions. fn How many children other families have is irrelevant. The
counsel from the First Presidency on these matters emphasizes the personal
nature of these decisions.
Another myth is that if anything goes wrong with the spiritual or emotional
climate of the home, the woman is to blame. Blame never solves problems. Whether
a woman blames herself or her husband blames her, neither is solving the problem
of what the climate in the home should be. In fact, the very blaming causes a
bad climate.
A woman may hesitate to say anything she feels might diminish or belittle her
husband in your eyes. If a counselor is not equipped to help her speak freely,
he may want to direct her to someone who can. He may also need to help her learn
to talk to her husband in new or different ways. He might say, "Are you
willing to try a different line of communication?" or "What might you
say instead?" or "I know you don't want to be in an inferior position.
Let's practice saying what you feel in another way."
A woman may benefit from learning to talk honestly and straightforwardly with
her husband about her feelings. For example, a woman who has been quietly
accepting undue criticism from her husband for a long time may want to change
this negative pattern. She needs to tell her husband in a frank but loving way
that she does not like being put down, that being criticized hurts her, and that
it is harming their relationship. She might say to him that she realizes only he
can change his behavior, but that she wants him to know what his negative
behavior means to her. fn
It is a myth that every Latter-day Saint woman should somehow fit into the
same mold. Help the women you counsel to understand that they do not have to
compete with other Latter-day Saint women! Stress their individuality and urge
them not to compare their family, husband, or children with anyone else's. Being
good at some things and mediocre at others is typical of most people. God asks
us to strive for perfection, but he does not require perfection before he
extends his love to us. But as we become perfect in love, then other
kinds of progress or perfection follow. When women compare themselves to others,
they lose sight of the very principles they are striving to live, and they miss
opportunities to either learn from the strengths of others or to help those with
other needs.
Every woman is different from every other woman, and has different needs at
the various stages of her life. For example, if the woman you counseled to get
married at age twenty-one is still single at age thirty-five, you may find it
more appropriate to support her in her career choice than to harp on the theme
"You ought to get married!" Carrying out such counsel is hardly
something she can do alone. Counseling a woman to stay home and not work may be
appropriate for a young mother with small children but inappropriate for a woman
of forty-five whose children are grown. Such counsel should focus on general
principles regarding family and work commitments; it should rarely involve
specific prescriptions. A woman's interests and talents that are a blessing to
her family can be offered outside the home as well. To take such talents beyond
the walls of her home does not mean she is disobedient, a bad mother, or a
marginal Church member. Nor is it wrong for a woman to limit her influence to
the home. In summary, there is joy to be found in the diversity of opportunity
available to women. They can approach such opportunities faithfully,
prayerfully, and individually.
It is a myth that a woman who raises questions is automatically on the road
to apostasy. Women in the Church today are asking many questions about doctrine
and Church procedures, just as men are. Think of women who raise questions as
people who are willing to discuss their thoughts, not as someone in rebellion.
Ask yourself, "Would I be upset, concerned, or feel threatened if this
question were coming from a man, or would I merely discuss it with him and then
try to find an answer?" If a woman is to be responsible for her own
salvation and is to get off the spiritual dole, she needs to ask honest
questions and seek honest answers. Honesty in questioning, not the questioning
itself, is the key to progress.
It is a myth that building only faith is sufficient to help someone. If a
woman is told that fasting and prayer alone will solve her problems, and then
she does fast and pray and the problems are not solved because she still lacks
the skills to solve her problems, her guilt is likely to increase; her
depression will then become more acute, and it will be that much more difficult
to help her out of the negative cycle she is experiencing. She may need tools or
skills to help her solve her problems. For example, suppose a couple were called
on a mission and were assigned to an area where driving a car was essential in
their work and the woman did not know how to drive a car. She would not be told
to go home and pray about it. This would be only the beginning of a solution to
her problem. Someone would need to teach her how to drive a car, and then
she should pray that she might use the new skill safely and correctly.
Similarly, if a woman lacks skills in dealing with those around her, she
deserves help in learning those skills. Fasting and prayer can be far more
effective when the person needing help has been given tools and skills that the
Lord can then help her use to solve her problems.
Single Women and Decisions about Marriage
Approximately one in six women do not marry, and many more become divorced or
widowed. One-third of the adult women in the United States do not have a man in
the home to support them. Though Latter-day Saint women do understand the
importance of families and family systems, not all of them will marry, bear
children, and have their own families in mortality. Most single Latter-day Saint
women would prefer to be married if they could, and therefore do not constantly
need to be told that they should be. A woman is not obliged to accept a proposal
of marriage to a man she does not love or wish to be with throughout eternity.
Joseph Fielding Smith wrote in "Elijah the Prophet and His Mission,"
published in the Utah Genealogical and Historical Magazine, January l921:
You good sisters, who are single and alone, do not fear, do not feel that
blessings are going to be withheld from you. You are not under any obligation or
necessity of accepting some proposal that comes to you which is distasteful for
fear you will come under condemnation. If in your hearts you feel that the
Gospel is true, and would under proper conditions receive these ordinances and
sealing blessings in the temple of the Lord, and that is your faith and your
hope and your desire, and if that does not come to you now, the Lord will make
it up, and you shall be blessed—for no blessing shall be withheld.
In his talk to women in September 1979, President Kimball said:
Sometimes to be tested and proved requires that we be temporarily deprived—but
righteous women and men will one day receive all—think of it, sisters—all
that our Father has! It is not only worth waiting for; it is worth living
for!
Meanwhile, one does not need to be married or a mother in order to keep the
first and second great commandments—those of loving God and our fellowmen—on
which Jesus said hang all the law and all the prophets. fn
Being single need not inhibit a single woman's efforts to strive for
exaltation. A woman who is single, who has no immediate marriage plans, and who
seeks a career or advanced degree is not necessarily making a negative statement
about marriage. She is probably taking intelligent steps to ensure her own
survival, success, and happiness.
Older single women should be supported in their singleness. They need to know
that it is all right to be alone; being single may be second choice, but it is
not the end of the world. Yes, families are first. But not all women can be
married, since in the twenty-and-over population women outnumber men in the
United States by 8.6 million.
It is not only permissible for women to be single and happy at the same time,
but crucial that women of every age find resources that will ensure their
happiness whatever their marital status. Helping older single women to adjust in
a positive and creative way to this reality calls for insight, understanding,
prayer, and freedom from prejudice in the counselor.
If a counselor has the attitude that a woman is not available to do the
Lord's work until some condition in her life changes—until she gets married,
remarries, and so on—then the counseling may have an unintended debilitating
effect. It is important to remember that every woman, no matter what her marital
status, has an earthly mission to perform. This may or may not be in ways that
we traditionally think of women serving the Lord. The outcome of any counseling
should be to help her, through continual righteous living, to discern directions
available to her that are consistent with the Lord's will.
Counseling Women Who Work
Many Latter-day Saint women work outside the home. Many are mothers with
small children still at home. The vast majority of such women are working for
compelling economic reasons and are in great need of support and encouragement.
Specific counsel on when to work is usually overstepping your responsibilities,
but many men and women are concerned about the consequences of wives' working.
When they seek your help about such matters, teach correct principles. Have
husbands and wives examine their own hearts on such sensitive decisions.
Whatever their decisions, your role is not to condemn. Children deserve to know
of the family financial circumstances and why their mother is working. A
mother's going to work can be an act of love for her children, and they should
be helped to understand this. Children can then be a source of support as the
family works through its financial difficulties together. The issue is always
what would be best for the family. Again, women and their situations differ
widely, and what may be appropriate for one might not be for another. Women with
an "empty nest" might greatly enhance their lives by working outside
the home.
Education for Women
At a Paris area conference in 1977, Sister Camilla Kimball said:
I would hope that every girl and woman here has the desire and ambition to
qualify in two vocations—that of homemaking, and that of preparing to earn a
living outside the home, if and when the occasion requires. An unmarried woman
is always happier if she has a vocation in which she can be socially of service
and financially independent. . . . Any married woman may become a widow without
warning. Property may vanish as readily as a husband may die. Thus, any woman
may be under the necessity of earning her living and helping to support
dependent children. If she has been trained for the duties and emergencies of
life which may come to her, she will be much happier and have a greater sense of
security. fn
Fortunate is the young woman who received counsel and encouragement in her
youth as to the importance of preparing to take care of herself—and then did.
Many women have not so prepared, however, and when they find themselves suddenly
widowed or divorced, they do not have the necessary skills to support
themselves, let alone their children. Teenage girls who become mothers before
age seventeen rarely finish high school and frequently find themselves having to
rely on Church or state welfare. Many older women who are left with no husband
to support them are locked into low-paying or dead-end jobs because they have
acquired no marketable skills. As difficult as it may be for these women to take
the time to acquire such skills, three or four years of schooling in their
twenties, thirties, or forties can be a great hedge against a life of poverty or
welfare dependence. The government now estimates it will cost over $135,000 to
raise one child to age eighteen. The financial implications to individual,
Church, and state are obvious.
With a woman's life span now seventy-nine years, most mothers will find
themselves with twenty to forty years left after their children are grown and
gone. Those who find themselves with time weighing heavily on their hands after
years of rearing children might be encouraged to go back to school to broaden
their experiences through further education.
Traumatic Changes
Major changes in women's lives, such as childbirth, death of a loved one,
divorce, or a move, may take up to three years to adjust to. Sometimes putting a
woman in touch with another woman who has faced and survived similar experiences
may be very helpful to her, depending on the maturity of those she might talk
with. Some of these experiences are discussed below.
Divorce
Divorced women are particularly vulnerable to outside influences because they
are often forced into the working world for reasons of financial survival. Many
are unprepared for the fact that even some Latter-day Saint men might treat
women unfairly. Some men feel that they should make all decisions and be in
charge even though they may sometimes defer to a woman (often in a condescending
way). Also, there may be times when they are patronizing or unnecessarily
distant in relationships with women who are not related to them.
Some Latter-day Saint women find that some men who are not Church members
listen to them, admire them, are likely to treat them as equals, are socially at
ease with them, and are great fun. Such women, therefore, may think they are
safe with these men when sometimes they are not! Some nonmember men are
agreeable, sharing, and accepting, but many lean toward a relaxed moral
standard, and divorced or widowed Latter-day Saint women are often vulnerable
and ill equipped to deal with these men and their standards. In some geographic
areas or other circumstances nonmembers may be the only marriageable men
available, and so the social life of single Latter-day Saint women will suffer
as a result. Latter-day Saint women in these circumstances should not give up
their standards, and might need to be counseled not to become involved in
situations "over their heads."
Abuse
If a woman complains of abuse—mental or physical—believe her. To assume
that she "asked for it" or "deserved it" would be incredibly
un-Christlike. There is no excuse—ever—for abuse, and it should not be
tolerated in any form. It is not possible for a woman to have true love and
trust for any person who abuses her. Certainly the abuser has as great a need to
receive counseling as the person who is abused. Dismissing complaints as
exaggerated or as too bizarre to be real may cause you to overlook a nest of
real problems. As you develop your questioning skills, you may discover problems
more serious than a woman is at first willing to disclose.
Whatever form the abuse has taken, her self-esteem is likely to be extremely
low or even nonexistent. It will undoubtedly take time and a great amount of
positive reinforcement from you and others to help her begin to see herself and
her life in a positive light.
Excommunication or Disfellowshipment
As a sister unfolds her story, you may see that her problems arise from
serious sins that will demand considerable repentance and demand court action
such as disfellowshipment or excommunication. Even when such action is
necessary, it is important that the woman feel loved and accepted and that she
know that both you and the Lord can hate her sin but still love her. A woman
facing Church court action needs assurance that she can be helped and that all
is not lost. Women in despair must feel there can be room for them in the
Church, no matter how serious their problems. Some women who are in deep
depression, not knowing who they are or where they stand in God's eyes, may need
loving support to learn that simply leaving the Church is not the right
or only solution to their problems. No matter how serious a woman's situation
is, help her to use it as a steppingstone back into the Church.
More Responses and Resources
As you counsel, you will recognize that some women are emotionally or
psychologically impaired. If you sense a strong need to refer such a woman to a
professional counselor, be sure she understands that you feel good about her
getting it. There is no stigma attached to seeking professional counseling.
Lay counselors need to be realistic and modest about their own abilities and
time commitments. It is all right to say, "I don't know," and to
recognize that the person being counseled needs either more help or a different
kind of help than you are prepared to give.
Among the professionals you have to call upon, be sure you have some who can
be reached in emergencies after hours. Some counseling services are available
only from eight-to-five Monday through Friday. As you become familiar with the
counseling resources in your community, you can build relationships with
professionals you trust and who are sympathetic to the needs of Latter-day
Saints.
There are different kinds of counseling needs: medical, psychological, and
spiritual. If, as you work with a woman, you find that she exhibits bizarre
behavior, that together you cannot find any reason for her behavior, that her
problems have a set pattern and have gone on for a long time, that she comes to
you over and over and seems not to be making any progress, or that you cannot
help her discern her responsibility for her own worth, value, and actions, you
may wish to seek assistance at a professional level. It is important, however,
that you still remain available to her for counsel.
Summary
Ultimately, of course, happiness lies within the individual. Others may help,
but ultimately each woman is responsible for her own positive relationships with
herself and with the world. The goal of every Latter-day Saint woman should be
to find joy in this life, to become strong, and to learn to take responsibility
for her own growth. The men in a woman's life need to wholeheartedly affirm her
in such righteous efforts. Eternal relationships of men and women should be
based on the strength of both, and any counseling with women should reflect that
goal.
Counseling Women: Notes
1. Ensign 8 (May 1978): 91-93.
2. Emphasis by President Spencer W. Kimball, Ensign 8 (November 1978):
106.
3. Ensign 9 (August 1979): 23-24.
4. C. Kay Allen, Journey from Fear to Love (Denver, Colorado: Human
Values Institute, 1980).
5. Spencer W. Kimball, "The Role of Righteous Women," Ensign 9
(November 1979): 103.
6. Camilla Kimball, "A Woman's Preparation," Ensign 7 (March
1977): 59.
Suggested Readings
C. Kay Allen, Journey from Fear to Love (Denver, Colorado: Human
Values Institute, 1980).
Carlfred Broderick, Couples (New York: Simon & Schuster, 1979).
Sterling Ellsworth, Tale of Two Selves (Ellsworth Printing, 1978).
About the Author
Ida Smith, former director of the Women's Research Institute at Brigham Young
University, holds a bachelor's degree in political science from the University
of Utah. Having had many years of experience in education, business, and
industry before coming to BYU, she has coordinated research projects concerning
women's issues and consulted with women's organizations on the needs of women in
the Church. She now serves with the BYU alumni office.
Sister Smith has spoken to over a hundred different groups between 1979 and
1983 on topics relating to women's concerns.
She has held numerous ward, stake, and regional callings, including gospel
doctrine teacher, mother education teacher, counselor in a Young Women's
presidency, and Special Interest stake and regional chairman
Chapter 15 Counseling Women - Ida Smith
Counseling women implies certain
responsibilities that are not necessarily unique to counseling in Church
settings but that are crucial to blessing the lives of women in the Church. Too
often, women come away from counseling sessions feeling that they have not
really been listened to, that they have not had an opportunity to state their
entire problem before advice and counsel were given, that their concerns were
not believed or were trivialized by the counselor. Considering this, here are
some general guidelines for counseling with a woman: be honest with her; be a
safe refuge for her; keep her confidences. At first, the support and
understanding she receives from you will be more helpful than any information
you could impart.
Typically, a woman will be
grateful for your comfort and express appreciation for you. If you are a man,
take care not to misread her gratitude and expression of care for you as being
more than she intends. If her thankfulness were more than honest praise, she
would be out of bounds in her feelings, and if you were to respond improperly,
you would be dishonoring your responsibility. If your offer of help has been
genuine, then you are representing the Savior in charity. If her response is
honest, then she is communicating gratitude. It is not uncommon for a counselor
or client to claim to have "fallen in love" with a person they are
seeing. That kind of "love" is a counterfeit of genuine help. By being
concerned but not inappropriately intimate, you can be an oasis of help and
support.
Some Latter-day Saint women feel
that certain situations generated by our culture put even greater pressure on
them than on women generally. Many women simply need a place to express their
feelings, assess their problems, and relieve themselves of burdens, with their
counselors giving no comment, no judgment, no condemnation. Until a woman is
allowed to do this, she will have little room in her mind for the principles and
thoughts you may want to share. The counselor who has empathy, understanding,
and compassion provides refuge for anyone in need of counseling.
As you acknowledge a woman's
suffering, acknowledge also that it will diminish. The pain she feels does not
need to continue at an intense level. It is important to first help reduce her
pain; after her wounds are attended to, she will be less likely to lash out,
inflicting suffering on herself as well as those around her. Do not talk down to
her or say, "You shouldn't feel that way!" Such comments reveal more
about your attitudes than about solutions to her problems. The feelings of those
in emotional pain are real. If you believe, even subconsciously, that she is an
inadequate person, your words and attitude will reveal it. Without your faith in
her abilities and talents, without acknowledging her as capable, you have little
to offer.
Sometimes a woman whose suffering
is hidden may come for help. Her outward appearance, her standing in the Church
or community, or her husband's position may hide her personal struggles. Many
people put on a good facade. Take a woman's cries for help seriously; then you
can assess how desperate she really may be.
Few problems develop overnight. A
woman can be helped by understanding that she can grow out of a problem just as
she grew into it. Like losing weight, psychological and emotional growth need to
be measured in small increments. Sometimes just hanging on is progress, and the desire
to survive is growth. When a woman has suffered serious depression and feels
worthless, help her focus on just fifteen minutes of positive thinking each day,
one day at a time, or to hold one happy thought or feeling every day.
Acknowledging even one happy thought a week may be progress for some.
Help the woman to understand that
it is not possible for you to make everything right for her. She must learn to
do that for herself—with help and support from concerned others. Remember that
often women have been raised in a way that promotes dependence on someone other
than themselves. Often, that someone has been a man—father, husband, bishop,
or stake president. By fostering her own capacities and self-reliance, you can
help her take hold of her own life, including her own emotional health. You can
explain this to her. Elder Boyd K. Packer has spoken of the need for Latter-day
Saints to get off the spiritual dole. fn This is especially true for women who
have been socialized to be dependent on almost every level—physically,
mentally, spiritually, and emotionally.
Be slow to advise and quick to
support. Quick advice is often more judgmental than helpful. Support her in such
a way that she will carry her own burdens. Be wary of the "shoulds"
that you may not be authorized to suggest, such as "You should get
married," "You should not work," or "You should move."
Such prescriptions may ignore more fundamental principles the woman needs to
learn, such as self-understanding and self-reliance.
Sometimes a woman who asks for
counsel will be angry and depressed and not know why. You may find that her
history of dependence has helped cause her to be angry with her husband;
resentful of her children; rebellious toward priesthood, God, the Church, or any
other authority. The solution to these feelings is one she may reject at first:
she may need a closer relationship with God, a better understanding of her own
identity, and a clearer sense of her spiritual mission. She needs to understand
that the root of personal confidence is her own virtue, and that being a partner
in her marriage is an important key to her own salvation. (D&C 132:20.)
The purpose of eternal marriage is
that husband and wife can grow into Godhood together. Marriage must be a
partnership of equals. Contrary to culture or practice, woman is not meant to be
a junior partner in marriage. President Spencer W. Kimball stated in his
September 1978 address to women:
Marriage is a partnership. Each is
given a part of the work of life to do. The fact that some women and men
disregard their work and their opportunities does not change the program. When
we speak of marriage as a partnership, let us speak of marriage as full partnership.
We do not want our LDS women to be silent partners or limited
partners in that eternal assignment! Please be a contributing and full
partner. fn
If a woman has not already assumed
an equal partnership in her marriage, she should be encouraged and counseled to
do so. This may include counseling with her husband, particularly if he sees the
patriarchal role as one of domination and demands rather than one of loving
persuasion and righteous influence as taught in Doctrine and Covenants 121.
Although you must recognize your
own dependence on the Lord as you counsel, do not give the impression that all
you say is of divine inspiration, unless it is and you have the authority to
receive inspiration for that person. As one stake president said, "If you
are inspired, say so! She needs to know it is the Lord speaking and not you
alone. If you feel to advise, let the Lord do it through a blessing, but be very
sure you are doing the right thing for her." Anyone who counsels has a
profound responsibility to be righteous and to discern the will of the Lord.
When Men Counsel Women
The way a male counselor views his relationship with a female he is
counseling is of vital importance. If he feels, however subtly, that he is
superior to her or is just an extension of some other male in her life, he may
give inappropriate advice. But if he sees his role as that of a teacher, guide,
and one who has a right to bless her because of his Church position, then he is
serving her best interests.
Some women may not have had good relationships with their fathers, husbands,
or other men. We sometimes teach children that the love and concern our Heavenly
Father has for us is like the love and concern of our earthly fathers. But if a
woman has not enjoyed the love of an earthly father or husband, she will not
have had that example to teach her about a loving Heavenly Father. Your words
and actions should help her better envision Him. The scriptures counsel that if
we cannot learn to love our imperfect brothers, neighbors, husbands, and others
whom we have seen, we cannot claim to love God whom we have not seen. (See 1
John 4:20-21.)
What if a woman is married to a tyrannical husband who misuses his
priesthood? What is her responsibility? Ideally, of course, it would be to
forgive him. This does not mean she should become a doormat to his
unrighteousness. It simply means that she will do all in her power to pursue a
right course of action herself. Her coming to you with a marital problem
grounded in the unrighteous dominion of her husband is in itself righteous and
responsible. If she has come alone, it is naive to think that her marital
problems will be solved by the two of you alone. A husband must repent of his
unrighteousness if his marriage is to be healed. If the husband does not abandon
his tyranny, there will be no solution.
Too many wives suffer the unrighteous dominion of men who dishonor their
priesthood. Sometimes a man uses "priesthood" to belittle, control, or
even physically abuse a woman. If the woman has difficulty in separating man from
priesthood, help her see that unrighteous behavior of such a man means
"amen" to his priesthood or authority. (See D&C 121:34-37.) When
there is such unrighteousness it does not mean that there is no hope for the
future. On the contrary, when husbands and wives repent and forgive, they can
solve their problems. Your task is to work toward that goal. This usually means
that, at some point, the husband of a woman will also need to be involved in
counseling with you.
Priesthood gives men the governing power in the Church. Men may need to be
counseled that this does not make them better, smarter, more blessed, more
capable of making correct decisions, more inspired, more logical, or more loved
of God than are women.
Righteous priesthood holders recognize the true status of women and know they
are equal to men in spiritual power, divine potential, and responsibility for
their callings. Women need to know that they have just as much right to
inspiration as men do. But often they do not understand their right to
inspiration and revelation and therefore receive none, because they expect none.
Help the women you counsel to recognize their own right to receive personal
revelation. You might ask, "What is your recommendation in this
situation?" You might suggest, "The Lord will reveal your
responsibility to you, so let's examine your reservoir of help."
Women have great recuperative powers, and they must learn to draw upon the Lord
for their strength.
Help each woman you counsel to understand agency and how to choose the right.
Encourage her to study the scriptures and to do her own thinking. If she is
depressed, sees herself in an inferior position, or is angry, she may feel
incapable of praying to a God who she thinks neither hears her nor cares about
her. But such negative feelings can be left behind as she feels the Lord's love
and guidance.
President Spencer W. Kimball has urged the sisters of the Church to become
gospel scholars. They deserve to be challenged to learn and teach correct
doctrine. Occasionally leaders ask only the husband to speak on doctrinal
subjects in sacrament meeting while they ask the wife to speak about her family.
Such assignments will tend to weaken, not strengthen, the woman's resolve to
become a gospel scholar.
The family dimension of a woman's gospel scholarship is especially crucial.
Pearl Buck's statement that "no man ever recovers fully from the ignorance
of his mother" may be even more serious if the ignorance is spiritual. To
underestimate the importance of the woman's spiritual influence in the home is
disastrous. Though a husband and father should be a spiritual leader in the
home, the wife and mother has an equal responsibility to develop her spiritual
leadership.
Myths about Women
There are a number of myths that may distract the counselor, the woman he
counsels, or both. One such myth is that priesthood leaders have ready answers
to questions about family size. Such concerns should be the responsibility of a
wife and a husband with the Lord. Basic questions such as whether to use birth
control and how often to have children should be taken to the Lord by a woman
and her husband. Different couples may receive different answers concerning
their questions. fn How many children other families have is irrelevant. The
counsel from the First Presidency on these matters emphasizes the personal
nature of these decisions.
Another myth is that if anything goes wrong with the spiritual or emotional
climate of the home, the woman is to blame. Blame never solves problems. Whether
a woman blames herself or her husband blames her, neither is solving the problem
of what the climate in the home should be. In fact, the very blaming causes a
bad climate.
A woman may hesitate to say anything she feels might diminish or belittle her
husband in your eyes. If a counselor is not equipped to help her speak freely,
he may want to direct her to someone who can. He may also need to help her learn
to talk to her husband in new or different ways. He might say, "Are you
willing to try a different line of communication?" or "What might you
say instead?" or "I know you don't want to be in an inferior position.
Let's practice saying what you feel in another way."
A woman may benefit from learning to talk honestly and straightforwardly with
her husband about her feelings. For example, a woman who has been quietly
accepting undue criticism from her husband for a long time may want to change
this negative pattern. She needs to tell her husband in a frank but loving way
that she does not like being put down, that being criticized hurts her, and that
it is harming their relationship. She might say to him that she realizes only he
can change his behavior, but that she wants him to know what his negative
behavior means to her. fn
It is a myth that every Latter-day Saint woman should somehow fit into the
same mold. Help the women you counsel to understand that they do not have to
compete with other Latter-day Saint women! Stress their individuality and urge
them not to compare their family, husband, or children with anyone else's. Being
good at some things and mediocre at others is typical of most people. God asks
us to strive for perfection, but he does not require perfection before he
extends his love to us. But as we become perfect in love, then other
kinds of progress or perfection follow. When women compare themselves to others,
they lose sight of the very principles they are striving to live, and they miss
opportunities to either learn from the strengths of others or to help those with
other needs.
Every woman is different from every other woman, and has different needs at
the various stages of her life. For example, if the woman you counseled to get
married at age twenty-one is still single at age thirty-five, you may find it
more appropriate to support her in her career choice than to harp on the theme
"You ought to get married!" Carrying out such counsel is hardly
something she can do alone. Counseling a woman to stay home and not work may be
appropriate for a young mother with small children but inappropriate for a woman
of forty-five whose children are grown. Such counsel should focus on general
principles regarding family and work commitments; it should rarely involve
specific prescriptions. A woman's interests and talents that are a blessing to
her family can be offered outside the home as well. To take such talents beyond
the walls of her home does not mean she is disobedient, a bad mother, or a
marginal Church member. Nor is it wrong for a woman to limit her influence to
the home. In summary, there is joy to be found in the diversity of opportunity
available to women. They can approach such opportunities faithfully,
prayerfully, and individually.
It is a myth that a woman who raises questions is automatically on the road
to apostasy. Women in the Church today are asking many questions about doctrine
and Church procedures, just as men are. Think of women who raise questions as
people who are willing to discuss their thoughts, not as someone in rebellion.
Ask yourself, "Would I be upset, concerned, or feel threatened if this
question were coming from a man, or would I merely discuss it with him and then
try to find an answer?" If a woman is to be responsible for her own
salvation and is to get off the spiritual dole, she needs to ask honest
questions and seek honest answers. Honesty in questioning, not the questioning
itself, is the key to progress.
It is a myth that building only faith is sufficient to help someone. If a
woman is told that fasting and prayer alone will solve her problems, and then
she does fast and pray and the problems are not solved because she still lacks
the skills to solve her problems, her guilt is likely to increase; her
depression will then become more acute, and it will be that much more difficult
to help her out of the negative cycle she is experiencing. She may need tools or
skills to help her solve her problems. For example, suppose a couple were called
on a mission and were assigned to an area where driving a car was essential in
their work and the woman did not know how to drive a car. She would not be told
to go home and pray about it. This would be only the beginning of a solution to
her problem. Someone would need to teach her how to drive a car, and then
she should pray that she might use the new skill safely and correctly.
Similarly, if a woman lacks skills in dealing with those around her, she
deserves help in learning those skills. Fasting and prayer can be far more
effective when the person needing help has been given tools and skills that the
Lord can then help her use to solve her problems.
Single Women and Decisions about Marriage
Approximately one in six women do not marry, and many more become divorced or
widowed. One-third of the adult women in the United States do not have a man in
the home to support them. Though Latter-day Saint women do understand the
importance of families and family systems, not all of them will marry, bear
children, and have their own families in mortality. Most single Latter-day Saint
women would prefer to be married if they could, and therefore do not constantly
need to be told that they should be. A woman is not obliged to accept a proposal
of marriage to a man she does not love or wish to be with throughout eternity.
Joseph Fielding Smith wrote in "Elijah the Prophet and His Mission,"
published in the Utah Genealogical and Historical Magazine, January l921:
You good sisters, who are single and alone, do not fear, do not feel that
blessings are going to be withheld from you. You are not under any obligation or
necessity of accepting some proposal that comes to you which is distasteful for
fear you will come under condemnation. If in your hearts you feel that the
Gospel is true, and would under proper conditions receive these ordinances and
sealing blessings in the temple of the Lord, and that is your faith and your
hope and your desire, and if that does not come to you now, the Lord will make
it up, and you shall be blessed—for no blessing shall be withheld.
In his talk to women in September 1979, President Kimball said:
Sometimes to be tested and proved requires that we be temporarily deprived—but
righteous women and men will one day receive all—think of it, sisters—all
that our Father has! It is not only worth waiting for; it is worth living
for!
Meanwhile, one does not need to be married or a mother in order to keep the
first and second great commandments—those of loving God and our fellowmen—on
which Jesus said hang all the law and all the prophets. fn
Being single need not inhibit a single woman's efforts to strive for
exaltation. A woman who is single, who has no immediate marriage plans, and who
seeks a career or advanced degree is not necessarily making a negative statement
about marriage. She is probably taking intelligent steps to ensure her own
survival, success, and happiness.
Older single women should be supported in their singleness. They need to know
that it is all right to be alone; being single may be second choice, but it is
not the end of the world. Yes, families are first. But not all women can be
married, since in the twenty-and-over population women outnumber men in the
United States by 8.6 million.
It is not only permissible for women to be single and happy at the same time,
but crucial that women of every age find resources that will ensure their
happiness whatever their marital status. Helping older single women to adjust in
a positive and creative way to this reality calls for insight, understanding,
prayer, and freedom from prejudice in the counselor.
If a counselor has the attitude that a woman is not available to do the
Lord's work until some condition in her life changes—until she gets married,
remarries, and so on—then the counseling may have an unintended debilitating
effect. It is important to remember that every woman, no matter what her marital
status, has an earthly mission to perform. This may or may not be in ways that
we traditionally think of women serving the Lord. The outcome of any counseling
should be to help her, through continual righteous living, to discern directions
available to her that are consistent with the Lord's will.
Counseling Women Who Work
Many Latter-day Saint women work outside the home. Many are mothers with
small children still at home. The vast majority of such women are working for
compelling economic reasons and are in great need of support and encouragement.
Specific counsel on when to work is usually overstepping your responsibilities,
but many men and women are concerned about the consequences of wives' working.
When they seek your help about such matters, teach correct principles. Have
husbands and wives examine their own hearts on such sensitive decisions.
Whatever their decisions, your role is not to condemn. Children deserve to know
of the family financial circumstances and why their mother is working. A
mother's going to work can be an act of love for her children, and they should
be helped to understand this. Children can then be a source of support as the
family works through its financial difficulties together. The issue is always
what would be best for the family. Again, women and their situations differ
widely, and what may be appropriate for one might not be for another. Women with
an "empty nest" might greatly enhance their lives by working outside
the home.
Education for Women
At a Paris area conference in 1977, Sister Camilla Kimball said:
I would hope that every girl and woman here has the desire and ambition to
qualify in two vocations—that of homemaking, and that of preparing to earn a
living outside the home, if and when the occasion requires. An unmarried woman
is always happier if she has a vocation in which she can be socially of service
and financially independent. . . . Any married woman may become a widow without
warning. Property may vanish as readily as a husband may die. Thus, any woman
may be under the necessity of earning her living and helping to support
dependent children. If she has been trained for the duties and emergencies of
life which may come to her, she will be much happier and have a greater sense of
security. fn
Fortunate is the young woman who received counsel and encouragement in her
youth as to the importance of preparing to take care of herself—and then did.
Many women have not so prepared, however, and when they find themselves suddenly
widowed or divorced, they do not have the necessary skills to support
themselves, let alone their children. Teenage girls who become mothers before
age seventeen rarely finish high school and frequently find themselves having to
rely on Church or state welfare. Many older women who are left with no husband
to support them are locked into low-paying or dead-end jobs because they have
acquired no marketable skills. As difficult as it may be for these women to take
the time to acquire such skills, three or four years of schooling in their
twenties, thirties, or forties can be a great hedge against a life of poverty or
welfare dependence. The government now estimates it will cost over $135,000 to
raise one child to age eighteen. The financial implications to individual,
Church, and state are obvious.
With a woman's life span now seventy-nine years, most mothers will find
themselves with twenty to forty years left after their children are grown and
gone. Those who find themselves with time weighing heavily on their hands after
years of rearing children might be encouraged to go back to school to broaden
their experiences through further education.
Traumatic Changes
Major changes in women's lives, such as childbirth, death of a loved one,
divorce, or a move, may take up to three years to adjust to. Sometimes putting a
woman in touch with another woman who has faced and survived similar experiences
may be very helpful to her, depending on the maturity of those she might talk
with. Some of these experiences are discussed below.
Divorce
Divorced women are particularly vulnerable to outside influences because they
are often forced into the working world for reasons of financial survival. Many
are unprepared for the fact that even some Latter-day Saint men might treat
women unfairly. Some men feel that they should make all decisions and be in
charge even though they may sometimes defer to a woman (often in a condescending
way). Also, there may be times when they are patronizing or unnecessarily
distant in relationships with women who are not related to them.
Some Latter-day Saint women find that some men who are not Church members
listen to them, admire them, are likely to treat them as equals, are socially at
ease with them, and are great fun. Such women, therefore, may think they are
safe with these men when sometimes they are not! Some nonmember men are
agreeable, sharing, and accepting, but many lean toward a relaxed moral
standard, and divorced or widowed Latter-day Saint women are often vulnerable
and ill equipped to deal with these men and their standards. In some geographic
areas or other circumstances nonmembers may be the only marriageable men
available, and so the social life of single Latter-day Saint women will suffer
as a result. Latter-day Saint women in these circumstances should not give up
their standards, and might need to be counseled not to become involved in
situations "over their heads."
Abuse
If a woman complains of abuse—mental or physical—believe her. To assume
that she "asked for it" or "deserved it" would be incredibly
un-Christlike. There is no excuse—ever—for abuse, and it should not be
tolerated in any form. It is not possible for a woman to have true love and
trust for any person who abuses her. Certainly the abuser has as great a need to
receive counseling as the person who is abused. Dismissing complaints as
exaggerated or as too bizarre to be real may cause you to overlook a nest of
real problems. As you develop your questioning skills, you may discover problems
more serious than a woman is at first willing to disclose.
Whatever form the abuse has taken, her self-esteem is likely to be extremely
low or even nonexistent. It will undoubtedly take time and a great amount of
positive reinforcement from you and others to help her begin to see herself and
her life in a positive light.
Excommunication or Disfellowshipment
As a sister unfolds her story, you may see that her problems arise from
serious sins that will demand considerable repentance and demand court action
such as disfellowshipment or excommunication. Even when such action is
necessary, it is important that the woman feel loved and accepted and that she
know that both you and the Lord can hate her sin but still love her. A woman
facing Church court action needs assurance that she can be helped and that all
is not lost. Women in despair must feel there can be room for them in the
Church, no matter how serious their problems. Some women who are in deep
depression, not knowing who they are or where they stand in God's eyes, may need
loving support to learn that simply leaving the Church is not the right
or only solution to their problems. No matter how serious a woman's situation
is, help her to use it as a steppingstone back into the Church.
More Responses and Resources
As you counsel, you will recognize that some women are emotionally or
psychologically impaired. If you sense a strong need to refer such a woman to a
professional counselor, be sure she understands that you feel good about her
getting it. There is no stigma attached to seeking professional counseling.
Lay counselors need to be realistic and modest about their own abilities and
time commitments. It is all right to say, "I don't know," and to
recognize that the person being counseled needs either more help or a different
kind of help than you are prepared to give.
Among the professionals you have to call upon, be sure you have some who can
be reached in emergencies after hours. Some counseling services are available
only from eight-to-five Monday through Friday. As you become familiar with the
counseling resources in your community, you can build relationships with
professionals you trust and who are sympathetic to the needs of Latter-day
Saints.
There are different kinds of counseling needs: medical, psychological, and
spiritual. If, as you work with a woman, you find that she exhibits bizarre
behavior, that together you cannot find any reason for her behavior, that her
problems have a set pattern and have gone on for a long time, that she comes to
you over and over and seems not to be making any progress, or that you cannot
help her discern her responsibility for her own worth, value, and actions, you
may wish to seek assistance at a professional level. It is important, however,
that you still remain available to her for counsel.
Summary
Ultimately, of course, happiness lies within the individual. Others may help,
but ultimately each woman is responsible for her own positive relationships with
herself and with the world. The goal of every Latter-day Saint woman should be
to find joy in this life, to become strong, and to learn to take responsibility
for her own growth. The men in a woman's life need to wholeheartedly affirm her
in such righteous efforts. Eternal relationships of men and women should be
based on the strength of both, and any counseling with women should reflect that
goal.
Counseling Women: Notes
1. Ensign 8 (May 1978): 91-93.
2. Emphasis by President Spencer W. Kimball, Ensign 8 (November 1978):
106.
3. Ensign 9 (August 1979): 23-24.
4. C. Kay Allen, Journey from Fear to Love (Denver, Colorado: Human
Values Institute, 1980).
5. Spencer W. Kimball, "The Role of Righteous Women," Ensign 9
(November 1979): 103.
6. Camilla Kimball, "A Woman's Preparation," Ensign 7 (March
1977): 59.
Suggested Readings
C. Kay Allen, Journey from Fear to Love (Denver, Colorado: Human
Values Institute, 1980).
Carlfred Broderick, Couples (New York: Simon & Schuster, 1979).
Sterling Ellsworth, Tale of Two Selves (Ellsworth Printing, 1978).
About the Author
Ida Smith, former director of the Women's Research Institute at Brigham Young
University, holds a bachelor's degree in political science from the University
of Utah. Having had many years of experience in education, business, and
industry before coming to BYU, she has coordinated research projects concerning
women's issues and consulted with women's organizations on the needs of women in
the Church. She now serves with the BYU alumni office.
Sister Smith has spoken to over a hundred different groups between 1979 and
1983 on topics relating to women's concerns.
She has held numerous ward, stake, and regional callings, including gospel
doctrine teacher, mother education teacher, counselor in a Young Women's
presidency, and Special Interest stake and regional chairman
|
|